Dealing With a Rogue Chicken

2018 Holiday Sale on herbal courses!

Ever have a misbehaving hen who has to have things her own way? A runaround girl who sneaks off to a secret rendezvous with the chicks next door? A free ranger who takes advantage of her privileges? A layer who doesn’t think the nice nest you made her is good enough?

We have.

Dealing with a Rogue Chicken- How we took control of one hen gone wild.

We were noticing that we were getting less eggs than usual for a few days. Disconcerting, to be sure. We were wondering if something was awry with one of our layers.

It should have occurred to us. We’ve seen the girls trying to cross the road a few times. Why didn’t we think of it sooner?

One night I was out teaching voice lessons and I got a text from my husband: “Someone’s been laying next door. There’s a full dozen blue eggs at the bottom of the neighbor’s driveway.”

Blue eggs- the clues led to the answer. Yes, the neighbors have chickens. But theirs are all brown layers- they don’t have Ameraucanas. And yes, it’s the neighbor with the goats. Maybe our neighbors will have to start a blog called, “They’re Not Our Chickens.”

We decided that the girls would have to be grounded til they got their act together. Back in the coop they went for three or four days. My hubby put up a temporary fence to give them a paddocked area for more ranging right in the middle of the grass. You’re on probation, chickies. Get used to it.

But that one sly hen kept flying the coop (literally). She managed to get out of the short-term paddock almost every day, so we had to keep opening up the coop door to let her back in again anyway.

Ten more eggs in the neighbor’s driveway. This free-range thing just wasn’t working. (But at least the alternate nest was in a predictable place.)

Tim tried again. He moved the coop to the perimeter of our yard, near the edge of a wooded area. He re-set up the fencing around the compost bin and some decent forage. He made sure this time to enclose the paddock more securely.

So far, so good. The birds seem much more content here than they did in the grassy circle they had the week before. We’re starting to get the proper amount of eggs again- in the nesting boxes instead of a driveway. And that rogue hen? She’s only managed to fly out once so far.

While I enjoyed having free range chickens, we decided that this is still pretty close to ranging them. They have a decently large area with compost, bugs, fresh growing plants, lots of leaves and dirt to dig through- AND they’re right near our spring-fed mini-pond. What more could they ask for?

We wanted to give the birds freedom. But apparently they couldn’t handle too much freedom. Will we try free ranging again? Oh, maybe after a while. But for now, they’re happy, healthy, safe- and learning to be well-behaved. Which is, after all, what any chicken mama would want for her babies.




5 thoughts on “Dealing With a Rogue Chicken

  1. Ricki @ The Questionable Homesteader

    Oh how I love this post. I live in an area where one side of the street is made up of 1/2 acre lots and the other side is 5 acre lots (sadly I’m on the half acre side) and the property on the opposite side have free range chickens. At first it used to bother the neighborhood, mostly because the chickens used to sleep on the road at night, and would not move for traffic. Our options used to be to run over the birds or get out and chase them off the road so you could drive by. The getting out was annoying, but having to clean up dead chicken was even worse. Things have improved over the years (they started making the chickens sleep in the coop) and for the most part, the chickens stay on their property. We only have 2 rogue chickens now, and my one neighbor loves it as she hasn’t had to buy eggs for a couple of years now…
    I like the idea of free range, but after living with “free range” chickens for the last couple of years, I personally think putting them in a pasture might be safer… especially if they like to cross the road…

    1. Abi Post author

      Haha! You’re right, they can be tricky! I figure that pastured chickens are just as good health-wise, because they still get to forage and exercise, but they don’t get into as much trouble. Now that I wrote this post, I found four of our five birds out of the paddock this morning. Ay yi yi.

  2. Pingback: 5 Truths About Free Range Chickens | A Farmish Kind of Life

  3. Anna

    I’ve got a rooster that keeps flying the cop about 5 times a day, and we can’t keep him in no matter what. (He’s probably out right now.) Any suggestions?

    1. Abi Post author

      You know, I wish I did have a suggestion! We had a rooster like that too. First we built much a much higher fence around his run, which worked except for the times he still wiggled out and then it was almost impossible for him to find his way back. I think really the only way of guaranteeing that they stay in is to have a completely enclosed run with real fencing. But we like the free-range style, so it’s rare that our birds really stay in the run area that they’re supposed to because they’re always flying over the edge. I’ve finally thrown up my hands in despair and watch them un-mulch our flower beds over and over. I wish you all the best!


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *